Tag Archives: ad-industry

Advertising. Stop reading the old brochure.

About a year ago, I had a thought: what if ‘advertising’ only existed for the past five years? Prior to that, it simply didn’t exist. No ‘madmen’ of the 60s. No exuberance of the 80s. Nothing prior to 2020.

It’s an interesting exercise because it removes any nostalgia or legacy you may hold towards the industry, and allows you to judge it solely for what it is now.

And the truth is, we may call it ‘advertising’ but it has changed so much, in many ways the name is the only thing it shares with what it used to be.

Let’s look at a few reasons why.

1. Fundamentals of communication

Communication, to be successful, relies on two basic principles – one party sending a message, and the other party receiving it.

Maybe it’s easy if we think about it as throwing and catching.

Where much of advertising fails is in the second part.

Now, any creative worth their salt is very interested and considerate of how the audience ‘catches’ the message. However, typically, a client is more focused on the ‘throwing’ part. This is largely due to their lack of perspective; they’re usually too close to their own product and lack the ability to truly walk in their proposed customer’s shoes. That is why we see so many brand communications that might talk successfully to the client, their stakeholders, and their legal team, but fail to resonate with its true, intended audience.

In recent years, as the barriers to media have fallen, we’ve seen more and more throwing, with little regard for catching. We increasingly see people spewing copious amounts of shit – sorry, ‘content’– out into the world under the delusion that people are actually interested in seeing/reading/listening to it.

Truth is that, mostly, they’re not.

2. The stature of media

Once upon a time, simply appearing in media was a statement in itself. The subtext was ‘well, they must have something worth saying’.

However, with the advent of the internet and social media allowing everyday individuals to publish and broadcast content without relying on traditional gatekeepers like major newspapers and TV networks, we’ve seen the democratisation of media.

And, with it, the stature of media has largely gone. So, pretty much the opposite of how De Beers managed ‘scarcity’ of diamonds to keep the value high.

Now, any mug with a phone can push something out into the world, helping to create a place of absolute saturation which lacks any real gravitas.

3. Communications aren’t created for people anymore

While I discussed gatekeeping of media above, we need to acknowledge it hasn’t gone away. It has simply changed form. Now we have gatekeeping of media by technology.

It started as things like SEO, where we tweaked copy to help convince search bots that our material was what people were looking for, and has now grown into tailoring communications primarily based on appeasing algorithms and AI filters. It is the technology who gets to decide who sees your communication, whether it be a CV, or commercial, or whatever.

The result is that business’s now focus on communicating to technology rather than to a human audience.

And tech people, while undoubtedly smart, perhaps are not the best purveyors of communication that is clear, effective, and human. Anyone who has ever attempted to manage or navigate the arse-end of a Meta Ads account will know exactly what I’m talking about. Even the fact that they think headlines and images can seemingly be randomly paired together like mixed up lego blocks shows they have no idea about how communication works. Tech, yes. Communication, no.

What’s more, we now have a world where machines are also doing the output. AI-generated dribble is communicating with algorithms and AI bots. Humans have been removed from the equation entirely. Machines are doing the throwing and the catching. I’m sure I don’t need to tell you where that leaves a piece of communication that’s based on evoking emotion.

4. The role of advertising in society

Look, nobody outside the industry has ever stood up and said, ‘I love advertising.’

However, there was a time when advertising formed a big part of popular culture. In some cases, it even led it.

But those times don’t really exist anymore. The Cadbury gorillas, Guinness surfers, and Apple think differents of the world are no longer. That time has passed.

You could argue that if you ran those for the first time today, they would not have the same effect they originally did.

The reason is the landscape has now changed and the audience isn’t going to ‘catch’ a communication in the same way it once did. These days, those comms would sit amongst a swathe of other stuff that’s littering people’s feeds. Of course, many of those other posts are not necessarily encumbered with having to sell something. Just weird stuff, made for the sake of novelty.

Strangely enough, many commercial comms don’t aim to entertain anymore. Most ads on socials tend to take the form of a testimonial (varying in degrees of believability) or a simple ‘this is how our product works’. No idea, rarely emotional, and sometimes with a strong reliance on an editing gimmick.

The communication rarely lives in the audience’s mind beyond the few seconds it may manage to claim in a person’s feed.

So, what’s the solution?

Despite the numerous people who jump on LinkedIn and proclaim to know the way things will go, nobody knows what the future holds. Anyone who says differently is full of it.

So, while I’m no Nostradamus, here are a few things for consideration.

On the media front, people are already tired of AI slop. They know they can’t truly believe or trust what they see or hear in their feeds anymore, so everything on social may become the modern-day equivalent of the cartoons on a Saturday morning – slightly amusing, but definitely not to be taken seriously.

This credibility issue may actually be the death of social platforms like Meta and see people turn away from it, or it may give rise to newer versions that can provide verified information. How that content might be verified or policed is the question.

There could be a big swing towards authenticity. Perhaps the plethora of AI generated things may be the final straw in a world of automated supermarket checkouts, online dating and digital events. Rather than a virtual world that resembles that of Ready Player One, people may actively seek real-world events, more in-person and tangible experiences and interactions.

If that’s the case, things like experiential marketing may thrive. Direct mail might even make a comeback, thanks to its tangible nature.

In short, as the world becomes more fabricated, people may increasingly seek what’s real.

DUSTIN LANE
Brand Strategy | Creative Concepts | Copywriting

Visit risinggiants.co or dustinlanecreative.com